Are you a democracy or a monarchy?

4 replies [Last post]
Madeleine's picture
Offline
Joined:
09/29/2011

A tacky mess: the masses vs. great design

Designers prune.

Left to its own devices, the mob will augment, accessorize, spam, degrade and noisify whatever they have access to, until it loses beauty and function and becomes something else.

The tragedy of the design commons.

A farmer's market with no entry requirements turns into a bazaar and then into a souvenir stand and finally into a flea market.

A bulletin board with no moderator or hierarchy becomes a random mess of affiliate posts and noise, where only a smart search engine is helpful.

An Apple product designed with user feedback would have thousands of extra features, multiple input methods and weigh 18 pounds.

(The best exception to this rule are some--not all--places where people live, including parts of Manhattan and Kibera, Kenya. But even in the best instances, as soon as commercial interests are served, it starts to fail).

It seems democratic and non-elitist to set it and forget it and let the users take over. But the tools we use (Wikipedia) and the brands we covet (Nike or Ducati) resolutely refuse to become democracies.

__________________

Everyday, for good or ill, we intersect with some else's story and become a part of it.

 

Arks's picture
Offline
Joined:
05/22/2010

Benevolent dictator.

Can't please eveybody, shouldn't even try to, but listening to suggestions is OK, even beneficial, as long as they're brief and not crazy.

__________________

All saints can do miracles, but few of them can keep hotel. ~ Mark Twain

 

Generic's picture
Offline
Joined:
02/24/2011

 I agree. Benevolent dictator is the best description.

__________________

Permission to quote in whole or in part, other than usage on this forum, is entirely forbidden.

 

Madeleine's picture
Offline
Joined:
09/29/2011

Ah, better one...benevolent dictator!

Madeleine's picture
Offline
Joined:
09/29/2011

I will say that we will listen to ideas. But, ultimately, we have to live with what we've created.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.