We stayed there about 5 years ago and it was fine for what it was. Location great..I had no complaints for what we paid...except for the thin walls, we got a real earful every night!Just do not stay at the Edison Hotel! It is blocks from Broadway and one block from Times Square BUT the door handle came off in my hand as we were trying to leave and there was no rush to come let us out nor any adjustment of anything although it was fixed in about an hour. We were on the 14th floor I think and all I could think of was - and it there had been an emergency????? Bathroom is so tiny you do not want to think about it.
I think I would love to see anything there. I wanted a comedy because my friend was battleong cancer and I thought something light would be great. Our other friend booked The Color Purple - but it was great too. We were glad we went - 2006..