I can definitely do large bottles of pump shampoo in the bathroom. I certainly wouldn't mind using that after someone else. As far as the pens go, I would put the URL on them and they would be for taking home.
I have read so many stories about people loving the B&B, but not being able to remember the name. We go to Destin for a couple of weeks every year (guess that will be coming to an end now) and I seriously couldn't tell you which condo we were at last summer.
Now that I'm going from user to provider, all of sudden that's important. Haha
~~g.
I think remembering a beach condo is a different scenario than remembering a B&B. You probably had no or relatively little hospitality service at the beach condo in Destin, right? It's kinda apples to oranges...
Re: people taking, leaving, and/or using bath amenities - Some people are like my dh, he will use & take everything in the way of individual bath amenities and doesn't care a twit about fragrance, type, style, logo, etc. He uses it while he's there & just grabs all that stuff because he figures he's paid for it and will use it sooner or later. I will use amenities that are better quality, non-allergen, or that I just like the brand. I might take it to remind me of the product OR the B&B. If I don't use it during my stay, it's because I packed my own stuff as a backup because I'm not sure if I'll have an allergy/sensitivity to what's in the room. This is the reason that I don't use anything in dispensers without the product content clearly labeled.
I did discover for our guests that they liked having antibacterial pump soap at the sink (we used various Bath & Body Works) and when we went to Gilchrist & Soames hotel amenities (a better known brand) that we went through more bath soap. A lot of folks do bring their own shampoo/conditioner I think because there are so many options out there & people get hooked on their own "product". Overall, business travelers tended to use all the bath amenities more.
I had all kinds of other amenities available & people commented on how I went the extra mile in that area. Guests didn't really clean us out either.
Just depends on what you want to do in your market.
.