I guess I'll comment more on the technical side
http://gtmetrix.com/reports/tanglewoodhall.com/b8l6LxMb
Page load time: 3.72s
Total page size: 1.80MB
Total number of requests:
75
This page has 15 external Javascript scripts. Try combining them into one.
This page has 12 external stylesheets. Try combining them into one.
I guess if you install and properly configure the WP Super Cache or W3 Total Cache plugin then your stats will go up a bit, but you still have a bit too many HTTP requests on the homepage, 75 is a bit excessive for such a small homepage.
The link :hover color in the footer (the golden color) makes the links completely unreadable.
If you insert small photos into the content, there is no need to link these images to themselves, like the photo of the house on the homepage. It adds an extra disturbance and a way for the visitor to close your website.
On the Gallery page please drop the photo carousel, it is confusing, annoying and too small.
Lose the text-align: justify, this is bad practice and will only hurt your business.
Personally I would increase the line-height for the paragraphs (currently you have 20px, 24-26 would be much better).
I would make the boats and the sand in the background a bit more opaque, so that they don't collide so much with the text color.
Copyright © 2014-2015 Inn at Tanglewood Hall. Having a range of years looks amateurish and is pretty much useless. Usually people have just the current year.
But all in all, it looks good, will get the job done. A bit of a retro feeling, probably is what you are going for
.