How do you respond to hagglers?

INNspiring.com | Innkeeper Forum & Innkeeping Resources

Help Support INNspiring.com | Innkeeper Forum & Innkeeping Resources:

An Old Tavernkeeper

Well-known member
May 4, 2014
Reaction score
About 1/3 of our Airbnb guests come back but the large number of those book direct. We have the advantage of having a vineyard on site and being 2 hours from DC, so if they are coming back to visit the vineyard we can snag them again.

Our issue with Airbnb guests is that they are generally cheap, dirty, wasteful and rude. Not all, but the majority.


Staff member
May 22, 2008
Reaction score
It does amaze me that we add 3% to our AirBnB rates to cover our commission, the guest plays a huge fee on top of that to AirBnB, and we still have so many Air bookings this year. All these people paying more than they'd have to if they'd just book direct. We have a little "book direct" card we put in their free coffee cup when they check out, letting them know they'll save on their next visit if they book direct.

One thing I've discovered is that while I get some guests who come back from AirBnB, our return rate for those guests is much lower than first-timers who book direct or even those who find us through other OTAs. It's like Air customers revel in trying different places, even though they found our place amazing in every way.
We’ve had air guests tell us they don’t pay a commission so it’s the same price no matter how they book. (Not true because they are paying my piece of the commission, but they don’t realize that.) Others have said they don’t trust air hosts so they want the 500 lb gorilla backing them up. (Seriously? You don’t trust the hosts but you’re going to stay there anyway?)

You’re correct, tho. More booking dot com guests come back as direct than air.